The Business Of Data Centres
AI data centres in Australia - Balancing economic growth and environmental impact
AI data centres in Australia - Balancing economic growth and environmental impact
Australia is fast becoming prime real estate for the growing AI data centre rollout. But why now?
As multi-billion-dollar projects expand, we're grappling with how to balance the economic potential with the pressure on our energy grids and water supplies.
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes is Senior Deputy Director of the UNSW Institute for Climate Risk and Response. She explains the economic drivers, environmental risks and how this data centre expansion could be done sustainably.
Want to know more?
For the latest news and research from UNSW Business School and AGSM @ UNSW Business School, subscribe to our industry stories at BusinessThink and follow us on LinkedIn: UNSW Business School and AGSM @ UNSW Business School.
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 00:00
So, the technology is new, and we are learning as we are going. But there are so many lessons learned from people working in this space, in climate, in finance, and across a broad range of social sciences that appreciate that now is not the time to say that we can't be creative about solutions.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 00:23
If you look at today's headlines, one thing is clear, as AI use accelerates globally, the data centres needed to support it are growing too. It's easy to think of AI as something intangible, a bit like the cloud. But in reality, it's powered by very physical, industrial-scale data centres. And increasingly, Australia is where some of them are being built. Our vast land, natural resources, and political stability make us an attractive choice for the tech companies. So, is this a win for the economy, or a potential climate risk? And who's actually footing the bill? This is The Business Of: AI Explained, a podcast by UNSW Business School. I'm Fahim Khondaker, Partner in Data and AI at BDO and Professor of Practice at UNSW. Joining me is Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes, Senior Deputy Director of the UNSW Institute for Climate Risk and Response, and Co-Director of the RISE Finance Lab. Welcome, Kristle.
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 01:22
Hi. Thank you.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 01:23
Let's start easy, what's a data centre, and what do they need to run?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 01:27
Sure, let's demystify data centres. So effectively, all it is is a warehouse, with rows and shelving of computer in terms of what they could be running, so the servers typically. And inside all of those are either CPUs or GPUs, right? And historically, they have been doing data comps for email websites, you know, very standard practice things, and now we're asking more of them. So, this is why we're moving into the GPU space because those chips can process a lot in parallel. And that's what you want when you want to be training or using an AI model, because that translates to getting a lot done all at one time. But what that means is now we're putting a lot more stress on the environment and the data centres in particular, because those types of chips generate a lot of heat.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 02:32
So you're saying we had data centres before?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 02:34
Yes.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 02:34
We just have more powerful ones now?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 02:36
We have ones that are computing more at once.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 02:40
And do we need more data centres, or is it the same ones we had, just getting more powerful?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 02:44
They are being repurposed to some degree, and they are also being expanded because the demand for AI is greater than what we would have seen before in terms of the need to actually compute, because the standard email and maybe website practice was actually quite small in comparison.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 03:06
But we have AI in Australia already. I used ChatGPT this morning. Sa a lot of us will ask the question, so what's going to be different with a data centre in Australia, versus the ChatGPT I used this morning?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 03:18
Let's talk about the electricity required to power a data centre. So, we referred to the chips inside a data centre before, right? These GPU chips put off a lot of heat. Because of that, they need to be cooled, and so either they're cooled with additional electricity, or they're cooled with water. Okay, and that's the typical process. We are looking at ways to do other coolants, but in the process right now, they're emitting a lot of heat, and they cannot continue to function if they overload. So we need to cool them. And this has real environmental impact because, first of all, it requires more electricity to be powering these higher computational data centres. Then, you have about the same amount of electricity is required in order to cool them. So, in the areas that they're operating, you're going to have additional demands on the grid, and you're going to have additional demands on the water system. So, in a lot of what's being discussed right now is ways to mitigate some of those potential negative externalities. But that's not the only impact. Data centres themselves, once it's cooled, the heat doesn't go away, it simply leaves the data centre, Meaning that the areas around the data centres are heated up, and that's great if you're in Finland. But here in Australia, we're already pretty hot. But beyond that, there's noise contribution, there's air pollution., there's the potential for fire risk due to the batteries installed. We're working on all of those things. We're working to mitigate those problems, but we don't necessarily have the clear picture yet. And so what that means is that, those communities around those data centres could be affected in ways that they didn't agree to. And we've even seen internationally, that house prices and property values in the areas around data centres are decreasing. So it's not a trivial question, to say the least. It is true. We run our models, and we are using ChatGPT, and Claude, and Gemini, but we're also participating in a chain of events that have real economic and environmental outcomes.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 05:43
Why all of a sudden is there such a big push for Australia in particular to want data centres?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 05:49
Sure. Well, there is a lot of energy behind that question. There's a lot of urgency and excitement over data centres, and it equates to a few things. But the first is potential sovereignty over this computation, right? So, we want to also make sure that if we become reliant on these models, that we have the access and control over being able to compute that here at home.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 06:15
You mentioned sovereignty earlier, and can you just explain to us what sovereignty means in this context, and what happens if we don't have it as Australia?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 06:23
When you're looking at our usage of just the internet, we are connected under underwater cables, right? And this allows Sydney and Australia to be connected worldwide. And that means that, we have access and connection and expectations like everybody else does. But there is something to be said about our reliance on this tool daily, and we would not want to offshore any of that potential control in case that was something that could be taken away. We are becoming quite reliant on this technology. We're using it in ways that I don't think we could have ever imagined. And so, we wouldn't want to put that necessarily in the hands of a foreign government, or body, simply because, well things look okay now-is. But there is still some sense of, what were to happen if we weren't to have access to it. But we also have to appreciate that we are very far, right? So there is a level of we actually benefit even on the latency situation and the connectivity for having those data centres here in New South Wales, because they're closer to those underwater cables, right? And a lot of that is what is being decided, when you're talking about the expansion of data centres and the ability for Australia to genuinely be able to power and control some of that technology, because we haven't gotten at all to the critical minerals required for chip construction and data sites. And a lot of that is controlled currently by China, but there's also some elements of Australia could be playing in that space as well, to be able to provide some of those critical minerals. And we see that that could be really an interesting way that Australia takes part of that discussion. But once again, it's taking things out of our ground and you know, building things on top of it. So is that the only use of those potential minerals? And you know, those questions need to be discussed before we, you know, haven't learned the right lessons and then, don't have a chance to, maybe, fix those mistakes.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 08:49
What happens at the local level, where the data centre gets implemented, what are some of the key considerations on the ground?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 08:55
Well, there are some economies in the U.S., for example, that are making data centres pay for hospitals or roads, right. So data centres ultimately are infrastructure. We have to be very mindful, however, that previous infrastructure projects are like roads, and you consider those relatively riskless, right? They're installed, and we use them. Are data centres as riskless? Probably not like roads. So, that needs to be compensated in some fashion, and that's why we're seeing backlash. But the reality is, until those certainties are in place, we need to really appreciate that problem. And Fahim, while that potential money is coming and being waved around, the guardrails have not been legislative yet. So we're outpacing slightly, some of those government guardrails by the actual investmen. And that's what I think those local communities we be watching very closely.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 09:58
If we go back to the previous conversation about the importance of sovereignty, and how urgent it is that we have sovereignty over this technology. It's balancing that with these environmental considerations, is that the difficultty that our leaders have to balance now?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 10:12
There is no technology gap when it comes to using renewables or being able to source the way that we're able to actually make it so that we're not an addition to the grid. There is simply a desire and a willingness gap, and when we're here saying, "well, you have the money, you're going to fund it." Then, that is what gets you over that hump to actually say, "okay, they're being powered with those renewables." And that's where we're seeing in Ireland, and in Singapore, other economies that have looked at this, and potentially even in Ireland's case, had put a moratorium on the data centre expansion until they could get a handle on the environmental requirements. And so, we're coming into a relatively mature market with a lot of lessons learned, we go in eyes wide open.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 11:01
Do we have the resources to do this sustainably?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 11:05
All of that technology exists, and in terms of resourcing it, I think you know UNSW is very well placed to have talked about how it is some of our researchers that have done the solar panels or the vanadium redox flow batteries. Or even looking at the graphite ways to appreciate that and take down the potential cooling costs. Right, so it's working in research, it's useful for industry, it's a matter of bringing those two pieces together and building it out with the resourcing available. And if all of that funding is available for expansion, it should be just as available for renewables.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 11:48
And who's funding these expansions? And the people who are funding and investing in this, have they factored in ESG and climate risk into their considerations I guess?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 11:59
Funding is interesting, because you do talk a lot about the companies themselves. You talk a lot about the state and federal governments. There's private credit, and then potentially just the traditional credit markets. So it is somewhat scattered in terms of all of the different options. But capital is typically not the problem. It's usually coordination. So the idea of whether or not they're considering these ESG, you know, specifications, it's about literally appreciating that climate risk. And you know, in my own research, we've seen that banks, specifically in the U.S, because that's where we have the data, are actively credit tightening in areas that are more exposed to climate risk even before natural disasters hit those areas. So when you translate here to Australia, we have a very concentrated financial market, right? Our big four banks operate in the same areas. Our capital market is relatively small and actually powered by a lot of these companies that are going to be really interested in this conversation. So, because of that, there is that understanding you can't easily diversify away some of these risks, so it should be paramount, they should be paying attention to it. And if they're not, please listen to this podcast and hear, to be paying attention to it.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 13:24
And you obviously specialise in climate risk, and in Australia, we've got droughts, floods, bushfires, you name it. If these keep increasing, what's the flow-on impact for the AI industry and the infrastructure that we're talking about? What happens there?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 13:37
They will become more common, and that's an excellent point because people think about how AI affects climate. We also need to think about how climate will affect AI. And the data centre is useless when the flood washes it away. Also, if it's generating heat to begin with, and you're in an area that is everly increasing in heat, well, that's not going to be great for that ability to compute within the data centre, same things. Bushfire risk, and at the end of the day, if anyone's going through a drought, the last place they're going to be wanting to share water with, is the data centre down the road. It's very topical on the minds of people watching for real life what's happening, and we see in the Asian Pacific Islands. This is not a tomorrow's problem. This is a far-gone yesterday's problem. And, as much as we want to be positive about the potential usage of AI, and there are potentially some positives and some benefits from it, we have to be very mindful of those costs.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 14:32
If we bring it back to AI infrastructure, and the rollout of AI infrastructure, have you seen in any of your research what different countries and different regions are doing, and what are they grappling with?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 14:52
I think what is important to appreciate is we are all grappling with this understanding and this, this learning process. And the learning curve at first was quite steep, right? Because we were excited and we moved forward with things, and we didn't necessarily appreciate what the potential costs could be. Now we've spoken about the electricity grid cost and potential water usage, but there's also additional potential ways for emissions, right? Building these, right? So the emissions forgone from the concrete, and the steel, and moving things in. There's also a really important piece about e-waste, right? I mean, how do we recycle, if we can recycle some of these new pieces being moved in? And it's, it's really hard to sometimes get pieces back out, and it's not necessarily commercially viable to recycle some of these. So what it's going to be is that, you have to replace these at really high timeframes. And so you're going to see that in certain areas like the EU, who has much more strict regulation, because they appreciate and are really feeling the acute effects of climate change in a way that we can maybe not see as, as acute in some areas of the world. They're rolling these things at a different paces. That being said, China really has a lot of the potential critical minerals for some of this chip construction. So because of that, they're in a different space in terms of what they're doing, because that requires the mining in order to take those out. And we can see that that's really interesting because, other countries then are stockpiling some of those to be able to anticipate what would be potential forward-looking needs. Right, so everybody is feeling like we're running the same race but at different paces.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 16:47
We often hear of really innovative stories around data centres around the world, and people doing really cool things with it. Can you tell us a few stories that you've come across?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 16:57
Sure. So I'm aware of one in the UK where they're using the excessive heat from a data centre to warm the swimming pool next door. And then, you've looked at places like in Louisiana or in Michigan, where they've rolled out some of the abilities to get these data centres in these local areas. But in exchange, they're asking for building roads or building hospitals, and to that point they're using the carrot of bringing them over to their locality, but then also saying, okay, but in return, we want you to invest in this local area.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 17:37
And then we often hear things in the media that are a little bit on the wild side. So, like we've heard about data servers in space?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 17:45
Yes.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 17:46
Data servers underwater in China as well. Is that viable?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 17:50
They're realistic in the sense that they exist, right? So there is a real data centre underwater, and SpaceX is attempting to get the permits to be able to put the satellites in space that take advantage of the solar panels, which will have great access to sun and not need the same type of evaporative use of water because they will be in space. But I think it comes back to being, just how mindful that financing decision must be. How large those costs must be, that people are taking such drastic steps to avoid them. Because it's not just one data centre, or maybe the second data centre. It's on those flow-on costs.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 18:36
And we are obviously talking pretty early days at the moment, and there's a few assumptions being made as we go along this journey. What could go wrong?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 18:45
Look, you can make your data centres as carbon neutral as possible, but if the models inside are simply powering the expansion and exploration of future fossil fuels, then it's game over. So that is the real stake here. But the stark reality is, that this technology could be used for good or bad. And the good could be, where we see actual applications. Like the UN is using it to detect methane leaks, and they're able to detect them earlier than humans. And with that, you're actually seeing the equivalent of things like millions of cars taken off the road if you're able to address those leaks early. But on the other side, that use of the current companies that drill and dig, being able to be more efficient in that process and pumping out more of that pollution, could be somewhere to the order of three to thirteen times, the amount of the emissions coming from the, what would then be considered trivial data centres. So the technology is new, and we are learning as we are going. But there are so many lessons learned from people working in this space, in climate, in finance, and across a broad range of social sciences, that appreciate that now is not the time to say that we can't be creative about solutions. And I have a bit of a thought experiment for you. So, we know what the industrial revolution looked like, and we've seen those photos, and you know, the smokestacks going into the air and seeing the black skies and what came of that and acid rain. And I want you to flip that script, and imagine a pristine blue sky because it was powered by solar panels, and wind turbines, and geothermal and all of this technology exists, and you know, flow batteries that have durations of 20 to 30 years. Things that, us humans, have already created, and we simply need to be putting them in practice. And that comes back to that, being aware of those decisions and financing those decisions with the willingness to stop the flow of what could just be path dependency. And say, we're going to do this, but we're going to do this the right way this time.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 21:16
What are some of the key questions? If we were going to be specific, to give people who are involved in this space, what are some of the key questions that we should all be asking?
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 21:25
Personally, I would want them to do more. I would want them to say, we have this incredible new technology, and we seem to have funding for days. So, what is the best we could do with this? What could we genuinely create with a product now? We could be solving these global challenges, and I think climate change is right up there with the global challenges to solve.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 21:54
Kristle, that's been really insightful. Thank you so much for joining us.
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes 21:56
Thank you for having me.
Professor Fahim Khondaker 21:58
Associate Professor Kristle Romero Cortes is Senior Deputy Director of the UNSW Institute for Climate Risk and Response, and Co-Director of the RISE Finance Lab. If you enjoyed this conversation, hit subscribe wherever you're listening or watching, and leave us a rating or review. It really helps more people find the show. The Business Of is brought to you by the University of New South Wales Business School, and produced with Deadset Studios.